Tuesday, June 21, 2011

The Asylum


The evidence is damming. Civilization and its latest clone Globalization is a failed system if measured against its ability to eliminate suffering on this planet. I prefer to use human suffering as a measure rather than other narrower measures such as money, property, or material things. I think suffering can be more clearly indicated by the infant mortality rates (IMR). For infants that die of malnutrition, starvation, sickness, injury or war can surely be said to be suffering.

In the process of eliminating suffering from humans I believe the spin off benefits to the other life forms on the planet and indeed the planets eco-system itself can function with less harm being done.  The input to the system is human creative energy and the output is the amount of suffering produced by the system.

After decades of thinking about and studying the system from within I have come to the inescapable conclusion that the root cause of the failure of the system is the system itself. It is fatally flawed at the conceptual level. No amount of band aids will save this system. Radical surgery or a magic bullet will not change the outcome. The system is designed to allow the few to control the many in a top down hierarchy that has no clear outcome goal.

In the beginning I believed the system was not only correct but had the potential to eliminate suffering from the planet. I supported the system by learning it, practicing it and being an advocate for it. At that time I thought that my ignorance of the system was the issue and once I had sufficient understanding of the system I could help achieve the desired outcome. I believed the system had potential. I had hope.

After I gained a deeper understanding of the system and moved up in the ranking order of the system, I realized that others above me within the system who understood the system allowed the system to produce increased, not decreased suffering. They had no interest in the outcome being content with the benefits of the system to themselves. The evidence was everywhere I cared to look.

So what to think? If the higher level people in the system had the understanding they could not be ignorant? Then the thought occurred to me perhaps they were stupid. The decisions they continually made certainly appeared stupid to me. So I moved to the thought that system is stupid phase.

Now I thought that if the stupid people were replaced with clever people the outcome must surely be achievable? I soon found that the system turned the clever people into stupid people who made stupid decisions. Why? Because to get up in the system a person had to prove that they were just as stupid as the people above them. Meanwhile the evidence continued to mount that the outcome was even more obscure and less likely to be achieved. What to think now?

Next I thought if clever people could make stupid decisions after a brief exposure to rank within the system, then maybe the system was somehow malevolent. Maybe it turned good, well-meaning people into bad people? But how? This was my conspiracy theory phase. But where is the evidence for conspiracy? I could not find it. Sure in isolated instances there were conspiracies aplenty but a system wide conspiracy? I don’t think so. That line of thought sailed dangerously close to paranoia.

Humans have inhabited this planet as far as I can tell for around 2.5 million years. Homo habilis, the first species to be described as distinctly human, began to appear, although only a handful of specimens have ever been found. But the existence of the city states, a relatively new human creation, has plenty of evidence to support this idea of a model for human Civilization.





Mesopotamia saw the rise of the city-states in the 4th millennium BCE. It was in these cities that the earliest known form of writing, cuneiform script, appeared c. 3000 BCE. The Civilization model (Top Down) was born and is practiced to this day in various forms. This system requires the participants to be completely insane. Thus began the insane system phase.

 But first a few words about Globalization. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the word "Globalization" was first employed in a publication entitled Towards New Education in 1930, to denote a holistic view of human experience in education.

Globalization, the concept, began with the idea that increasing the unification of the world's economic order through reduction of such barriers to international trade as tariffs, export fees, and import quotas would lead to a more equitable spread of economic prosperity around the world. What this had to do with the original idea of a holistic form of education is any one’s guess.

However today, globalization is usually recognized as being driven by a combination of; economic, technological, socio/cultural, political, and biological factors. The term can also refer to the transnational circulation of ideas, languages, or popular culture through acculturation. An aspect of the world which has gone through the process can be said to be globalized.

The paranoia is that Globalization is a new term for Western led control of the resources of the world based on military power. The Specter waiting in the shadows is “Crusades 2." The reality is that the 9 Billion human inhabitants of the planet by the year 2050 might prove to be an unstoppable force for change.

Why do I say Civilization as a system is insane? Any human idea that aims to divide humans is insane. Humans are at one with each other and the universe they exist in. Metaphorically they are holons within a holographic universe.

Any system that restricts human freedom is an insane system. Humans as holons in a holographic universe are free agents.

Any system that allows the few to control the many is an insane system. We as adults of the species are quite capable of controlling ourselves.

I use the word insane, a word normally used to describe the malfunction of the reasoning process in a human brain, to describe a process or system that has a defective function of process with no achievable outcome. The idea that the system is insane is my attempt to metaphorically describe a system as a person.

Humans are conceived dependent for life on their life support system (Birth Mother) and to a lesser extent their biological father. For it is from these two creators the infant inherits their genetic codes. With the cutting of the umbilical cord symbolically their life support system is changed fundamentally and irrevocably. They become dependent on the system for survival.









The top down system of civilization is designed to ensure the few control the many. There is no clear outcome specified. Instead the emphasis is on past perceived achievements and future potential benefits. The operation of the system is however given a great deal of attention. It is suggested at every possible moment that by trial and error and the learning of our mistakes the system is continually improving towards that elusive potential hope for a better world of less suffering.

This top down system was introduced as the most efficient system for the management of human affairs in the city state model of Mesopotamia (c 4,000 CBE) and subsequent civilizations. The idea was that order is more advantageous than chaos. Chaos and the consequent effect of disorder are seen by the system designers as the Achilles heals of the civilization system. To function most efficiently the system needs:

1. The idea of Division.

2. The idea of Dependence on the system for survival.

3. The idea of Fear of a world outside the system.



Division begins with the idea that we are not 'One.' The direct effect of this is segregation of the species, and the planet, indeed the universe, is the need for dependence on others. To be kept dependent we need to fear the consequences of independence. Let me consider briefly whether I as a human am naturally suited to a top down model that espouses division, dependence and fear.

As an infant we humans have no concept of division. We are in instinctive survival mode. We must learn division. Observe infants at play. As an infant we have no concept of dependence. We are in instinctive survival mode. We learn how to get our needs met. Observe infants at play and feeding. As an infant we have no concept of fear. We are in instinctive survival mode. We learn the concept of fear. Observe infants experiencing physical fear for the first time.

The infant human at the symbolic cutting of the cord enters the system. The infant human’s interface with the system takes a similar path across developed world cultures. The first encounter with the basic unit of the system is family. I use this term in order to describe, care givers whether biologically related or not.

The care givers, provide the needs of the child; food, clothing, shelter, protection from illness and physical intimacy. Care givers also introduce the concept of socialization. We are family. You, baby, are part of this family as distinct from that family over there.

Other facets of the family unit are also introduced to the thinking of the child. This is the head of the family, this is a grandparent, and this is an aunty and so on. With the family unit comes the idea of discipline. Baby must give up aspects of its freedom to live amicably within the social group. This requires the idea of discipline.

By the time the child is a toddler it is already well and truly in the system. The system is particularly interested in early childhood brain development to ensure the child will be able to enter the formal conditioning process called education. Here is an excerpt from the United Way Early Education Commission a community leadership collaborative supporting the United Way’s goal of ensuring children are ready for school.

Brain development research and understanding increased significantly in the 1990s, in part because of improvements in imaging technology. This research changed the understanding of how the brain develops, that underlying structures develop at the same time rather than sequentially. This underscores the importance of early childhood experiences and learning for a child’s early brain development and capacity for subsequent learning. Following are some key points from the articles abstracted for this meeting.


Brain Development Research – What We’ve Learned

·         Some aspects of the brain are genetically determined, and most neurons (nerve cells) are present at birth.

·         The structures supporting social, emotional and mental development are developed in early childhood; capacity to build these foundations is greatest in early childhood and decreases over time.

·         The brain develops rapidly in early childhood, creating periodic “blooms” of synapses (connections among neurons) that present “windows of opportunity” for brain development; by age six the brain is about 95% of the size of an adult brain.

·         The brain “prunes” the synapses that are not used, making it harder to acquire some learning later in life (e.g., foreign language), although the ability to learn continues through life.

·         Early stimulation -- interaction with parents, caregivers and the environment – is required for brain development; observation is not sufficient.

·         Ongoing “toxic” stress, such as from child abuse, neglect, maternal depression, substance abuse or family violence, can damage developing brain structures.

·         Poor nutrition can damage developing brain structures.



Implications – What We Need

·         Adequate, accessible medical care and nutrition for expectant and new mothers and young children.

·         Child and brain development education for expectant and new parents as well as non-parental caregivers so they understand the importance of interaction and stimulation.

·         Stimulating environments for young children.

·         Interactive relationships for young children.

·         Child abuse and neglect prevention.

·         Quality, accessible mental health services for parents.

·         Early identification of developmental concerns.

·         Weigh long-term benefits against short-term costs.



When I look at a list like this I see a tremendous amount of system interest in the child as a future system citizen. The system advocates, in this case United Way, suggest that the child’s natural brain development might not be normal without early intervention of mental health professionals and nutrition experts. To protect against the possibility of child abuse and neglect, system social services may be required. This will introduce the child to the idea of the law and the intrusion of state into private life. Economic factors such as the idea of economic efficiency, is not left out of the: What we need list above by weighing long term benefits against short term costs. The underlying subtle implication is fear. Fear of not doing the right thing by the child.



When I read such system messages from the Globalized world I also wonder about the suffering of the overwhelming majority of human children born into poverty, malnutrition, sickness and war. The majority of children in the world are subject to unacceptable infant mortality rates. According to the Save the Children State of the World's Mothers report, the world infant mortality rate (IMR) declined from 126 in 1960 to 57 in 2001. However, IMR was, and remains, higher in Less Developed Countries (LDCs). In 2001, the Infant Mortality Rate for Less Developed Countries (91) was about 10 times as large as it was for More Developed Countries (8). For Least Developed Countries, the Infant Mortality Rate is 17 times as high as it is for More Developed Countries. Also, while both LDCs and MDCs made dramatic reductions in infant mortality rates, reductions among less developed countries are, on average, much less than those among the more developed countries.

The point that is often missed when quoting statistics for human misery is that developed countries make up less than one billion of the nearly 7 billion humans on the planet. To put that another way is to say that a system in which approximately 15% of the world is classed as developed while 85% of the world is classed as either less developed or least developed after 5,000 years of civilization based on the top down model, is insane wouldn’t you agree?

© Copyright Geoff Ogilvie 2011











--------------------------------------------------------------------------------





[1] http://74.125.155.132/scholar?q=cache:vKNMy9eTPlkJ:scholar.google.com/+Learning+and+brain+growth+of+children&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5&as_vis=1